What’s the Difference Between Wood Shingles & Cedar Shakes?

Cedar Shingles & Wood Shake Roofing costs can vary across Canada. When it comes to roof coverings, wood can come in the form of shakes or shingles. For centuries, wood shakes have been used. They are separated from logs and are sometimes left split to maintain the textured, rough-hewn appearance.

The thick butt end of a wood shake instantly identifies it. With the introduction of commercial sawmills, a wood shake was frequently sawn after splitting to achieve a uniform backside.

Through sawing shakes on both sides, these sawmills created a perfectly consistent, and quality product with an even taper and equal thickness. A wood shingle is a kind of finished product.

Wood shakes and shingles are made from California redwood, western red cedar, cypress, spruce, and pine. The most common wood for shakes is cedar, but southern yellow pine is also very popular.

Pressure-treating wood shakes and shingles with fire retardants and chemical preservatives is an option.

Asphalt Shingles Come in a Variety of Styles of asphalt or composition, and shingles are usually made of organic material or fibreglass. Asphalt shingles are constructed on top of a foundation or pad made of absorbent cotton rags.

Natural fibres were eventually replaced by more easily available wood pulp or paper. Asphalt, also known as “felt,” was poured onto the foundation.

Cedar Shake Roof vs Asphalt Shingles – Which Are Better for Your House?

The roof constitutes a large portion of your house, and its presence has a significant impact on the resale value of your home. A beautiful roof increases the charm and curb appeal of your house and, when properly built, ensures that the residents remain dry and safe in all weather conditions.

Those objectives may be met with cedar or asphalt.

So, how do cedar shakes vary from asphalt shingles? Is one better than another? What are the two advantages and disadvantages? Is there a safer solution when all is considered?

According to Bravearooftile, Asphalt and cedar shakes are among the most common materials used on roofs today and although people are used to seeing asphalted shakes on most houses, cedar shakes are an excellent solution that is worth considering. They are both strong and ready for use, and over decades of continuous use, both proved successful. But which is better a cedar roof or an asphalt roof?

Cedar Shake Roof Installation Cost

According to Homeadvisor “One square (100 square feet) costs between $600 and $660 on average.” To have them installed on your home, find an experienced contractor in your area. Shake roofing is an expensive commodity requiring installation experience. The installation of your own roof will cause errors such as water leakage and structural damage. DIY systems can also cause shakes to be damaged and cancel the warranties on the device. It is safest to employ licensed roof installers for your job to add them to your house.

How Much Does It Cost to Install Cedar Shake Roof?

Modernize says, The roof construction cost on an average roofing installation of 1,800 square foot., with a shingle roof, from $7,649 to $11,474. When built on a regular single-story house, you can expect to pay $4,50 to $9,00 per sq. feet or $450 to $900 per square foot for wood shingles. Make sure you contact a roofing expert to get a finite idea of the roofing installation price.  Cedar shake roofs are great for developing that rustic appearance.

Cedar Shake Roof Cost

The estimated price range for the installation of a roof shake of three thousand feet is between 18,000 dollars and 20,000 dollars, or around 600 dollars to 670 per square. The low installation costs are approximately $16,000 and the higher-end costs are approximately $27,000. This will also depend on the cedar roofing shingles used as well. Cedar is definitely a premium product so expect to pay more, especially since the start of COVID-19.

Cedar wood roofing options is perhaps one of the most popular choice of wood types used because it is relatively budget-friendly, long-lasting, and sturdy. These roofs last about 30 years with good care, but must ultimately be substituted because the roofs will start to fall apart, rot and leak.

How long do cedar shingle roofs last?


If one compares cedar shingles’ longevity with asphalt shingles, the difference that can impact them should be kept in mind; how the ceiling has been built, where it is stored, and the overall consistency of the material.

A well-installed and well-maintained cedar shake roof made of good materials and chemically processed will last without problems for up to 30 years. However, this also involves maintaining the necessary repair.


Cedar shakes and shingles are good because they are very immune to items like insects.

Elements like wind can be well-held as well. However, they are not so well-held against humidity which can degrade and crack the wood. Wood shakes and shingles are not fireproof, either.

On the other side, you’ll find that asphalt will stand better with heavy rain’s and moisture by contrasting the wood shingles to asphalt shingles; however, strong winds are less likely to withstand.

Asphalt shingles can be quickly torn off when the wind speeds are high enough.

The costs of initial construction are not the only costs associated with these cedar shake roofing solutions.

When calculating the cost of a cedar shake roof vs asphalt shingles, you must also remember the necessary upkeep.

Cleaning and wooden roof maintenance work on cedar shake roofs is needed every 2 to 4 years to maintain the function and avoid excess moisture degradation. There are also chemical treatments used for fire and moisture resistance, which raises the cost of cedar shake roof vs asphalt roofing.

Asphalt shingles need deep cleaning a couple of years to maintain their appearance and ensure their durability. Shingles may be weakened by bad weather or inadequate maintenance.

People occasionally forget that there are other options when it comes to looking at roofing materials. There is far more out there than just cedar or asphalt shingles. Many people are becoming bored with the basic asphalt shingle look and looking for something new, but cedar shakes are a costly option that requires more maintenance than most are willing to commit to.

What is the cost of an Asphalt Shingle Roof?


The estimated roofing repair cost for an asphalt shingle roof ranges from $4,286 to $6,429 for a 1,800 square foot home. The cost of an asphalt shingle can vary based on the slope, moderate pitch, and size of your roof, as well as the consistency of the asphalt shingle you choose. You should expect to pay between $1.50 and $5.50 per square foot.

What is the cost to install an Asphalt Shingle Roof?

According to Fixr, the estimated cost of shingle installation ranges from $5,250 to $15,250, with the average homeowner spending $6,960 to install architectural asphalt shingles on a 1,500-square-foot roof. A roof with asphalt allows for some easy maintenance.

What is the Performance of Asphalt Singles?

Quality asphalt shingles can survive high winds, driving rain, scorching heat, a deep freeze, ice buildup, and hail. Many roofing materials have come and gone over the years, but asphalt shingles have stood the test of Mother Nature because of their superior performance.

In Conclusion

Asphalt shingles are the clear alternative over wood shakes in terms of expense and upkeep – the “Big Two” for most homeowners. In reality, asphalt shingles cover approximately 70% of Canadian roofs today.

Asphalt and Cedar Roofing Installation in Halifax, NS

Are you looking for asphalt, or cedar roofing installation in Halifax? The team of roofing professionals at Elite Roofing Halifax has you covered. Save time and hassle by contacting our team today to receive your free quote on your next roofing project. We’ll be able to discuss the best roof type for you and your home.

Disclaimer:  This article intends to offer general knowledge on this topic.  While every caution has been taken to provide accurate information, it does not intend as professional advice.  Please consult with an industry professional in your area to obtain proper advice based on your unique circumstances.  Elite Roofing Halifax and its parent company will not be held liable in any way should you suffer any loss/damage because of the information in this blog.